That's a bunch of nonsense. I'm sure they'll work just fine, just the same as they would on any other trim package.

 

I'm using the Weathertech's, I like them because they fit snug into the window crack. They also don't stick out very far from the window, gives it a better look I think.

 

You were 100% correct, I bought them and put them on, fits and looks great!

AVS Part# 94212

I will be asking Quadratec to say in their product description Installation Notes that it is confirmed to fit Limited XJ's to help avoid future confusion.

action shot:

 

Nice! Quadratec should definitely know better. So do those stick to the rubber trim?

 

Yes, they stick to the rubber trim, not to the metal door. pro-tip: all 4 parts are marked Left and Right. Front windows are obvious, but the rear window pieces are not, so take care to put them on correct side of the vehicle as marked.

here's another angle:

 

Those do look good. Maybe I should reconsider the stick-on kind. Thanks!

 

I've got the same ones as Squelchtone. Only things I've found to be negatives are
1. Like was mentioned earlier, your a-pillar becomes gigantic, especially since I have a snorkel.
2. Even the AVS ones get brittle after a few years. I've had mine for 6 years and had to "patch" a hole with gorilla tape (see pic) after a decent sized branch met up with the vent during a wheeling trip last year.
This past winter the other 3 cracked in a few places as well so I just removed them all. I'm probably not going to get another set though, simply due to knowing I'll just have to replace them again. Pulling them off, along with the adhesive, is a PITA.

 

Give the Weathertecs a shot, have had mine on for 7 years. No adhesives used. No cracks, no fading, durable, have drug tree branches down them. Worth it in my opinion.