When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go hereXJ (84-01)
All OEM related XJ specific tech. Examples, no start, general maintenance or anything that's stock.
SO I just replaced the radiator, water pump, thermostat...pretty much the entire cooling system. I've been driving around a bit and it will run about 210-218 going 60 mph, and going slow it wants to run 205 with a 195F thermostat in it. Is this normal?
This is what the thermostat looked before it was changed
This is the new stuff
Last edited by The BigFoot; 12-30-2017 at 03:56 PM.
Those numbers are not way off. At 60mph on the open road does it ever settle to a particular number (or close), or does it keep cycling between 210 and 218, like building up, and then falling down, then building back up again.
Those numbers are not way off. At 60mph on the open road does it ever settle to a particular number (or close), or does it keep cycling between 210 and 218, like building up, and then falling down, then building back up again.
Just cycles, but before changing everything it ran about 190-200 going 60
Usually, that cycling of temp at speed is an indication that the thermostat is not operating smooth as it should, and is letting temp build and then opening, then cooling and shutting down a bit, then repeating the cycle.
My old thermostat was doing exactly the same thing. Wasn't hurting anything, but the numbers were getting a little higher over time. Got to where it was cycling between 210-218 (just like yours) at highway speeds. It was even more pronounced after I changed the water pump last summer (bearing was going). So, I finally put a new one in a few months ago, and it now has exactly the numbers and behavior that you did before you changed yours.
Because the tstat is pretty easy, I would probably put another one in and see. Because I didn't want to do the job twice, I did boil some water on the stove at 200f to ensure it was opening properly (and smoothly) before installing it.
Also are you getting the temps from your gauge only? Try pulling it with an IR thermometer at the tstat housing (right by the coolant sensor), or via OBD2 to make sure that the numbers agree. (I monitor mine via obd2 via a homemade digital dash).
Usually, that cycling of temp at speed is an indication that the thermostat is not operating smooth as it should, and is letting temp build and then opening, then cooling and shutting down a bit, then repeating the cycle.
My old thermostat was doing exactly the same thing. Wasn't hurting anything, but the numbers were getting a little higher over time. Got to where it was cycling between 210-218 (just like yours) at highway speeds. It was even more pronounced after I changed the water pump last summer (bearing was going). So, I finally put a new one in a few months ago, and it now has exactly the numbers and behavior that you did before you changed yours.
Because the tstat is pretty easy, I would probably put another one in and see. Because I didn't want to do the job twice, I did boil some water on the stove at 200f to ensure it was opening properly (and smoothly) before installing it.
Also are you getting the temps from your gauge only? Try pulling it with an IR thermometer at the tstat housing (right by the coolant sensor), or via OBD2 to make sure that the numbers agree. (I monitor mine via obd2 via a homemade digital dash).
I never thought that, but I might swap it to a lower degree stat, because it likes to overheat in the Utah summer.
Infrared Thermometers can be bought at lots of places now. Any auto parts, large hardware, or harbor freight would have them.
Based on your logic, you could get a 32f thermostat and enjoy homemade ice cream right from the valve cover. I would stick to the 195f if I were you. A lower one will -not- keep it from overheating.
12-30-2017, 03:36 PM
Cooling help
