SYE Vs Hack n tap for Vibrations
Thread Starter
Member

Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 100
Likes: 4
From: Northeast
Year: 97
Model: Cherokee
Engine: 4.0L
I have Vibrations on the highway (2.5 inch lift), I've diagnosed its coming from the driveshaft.
I have the proper angles for a conventional driveshaft, but they are still present. T Case drop didn't help either. Ready to go with an SYE, I called Tom's driveshafts to figure out the logistics and they heavily persuaded against a Hack N Tap. They say the vibrations are worse then with a proper SYE. But maybe they're biased because they have customers call them who botched the installation and say the driveshaft is at fault.
Realistically, If I go for the Hack N Tap and do it right, is it going to be worse than with a Proper SYE? I really don't feel like opening up the transfer case and starting that whole can of worms. I could always switch the hack n tap out if vibrations are still present after I get the custom driveshaft, assuming I can make the hack n tap the same length as what an SYE would be.
It's not my tires, its not my front suspension, its not my front drive shaft, my exhaust is not hitting the crossmember.I bought another balanced conventional driveshaft with new u joints and it was somehow even worse on the highway. I need a double cardan
I have the proper angles for a conventional driveshaft, but they are still present. T Case drop didn't help either. Ready to go with an SYE, I called Tom's driveshafts to figure out the logistics and they heavily persuaded against a Hack N Tap. They say the vibrations are worse then with a proper SYE. But maybe they're biased because they have customers call them who botched the installation and say the driveshaft is at fault.
Realistically, If I go for the Hack N Tap and do it right, is it going to be worse than with a Proper SYE? I really don't feel like opening up the transfer case and starting that whole can of worms. I could always switch the hack n tap out if vibrations are still present after I get the custom driveshaft, assuming I can make the hack n tap the same length as what an SYE would be.
It's not my tires, its not my front suspension, its not my front drive shaft, my exhaust is not hitting the crossmember.I bought another balanced conventional driveshaft with new u joints and it was somehow even worse on the highway. I need a double cardan
ɹǝqɯǝW ɹoᴉuǝS





Joined: Sep 2023
Posts: 622
Likes: 164
From: Colorado
Year: 1992
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0 H.O.
Why not just do it right and go with SYE? These vehicles are basically becoming classics and flubbing your way into a solution as you've tried already with your transfer case drop is just going to cost you more time and monies.
Ditch the drop, switch to SYE, be happy.
Ditch the drop, switch to SYE, be happy.
CF Veteran




Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 2,607
Likes: 446
From: Michigan
Year: 1987 MJ, 1973 J2000, 1986 XJ, 08 JK
Model: Comanche (MJ)
Engine: 4.0L H.O
Where do you feel the vibration? Hands, feet, butt in your seat.
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Junior Member



Joined: Nov 2023
Posts: 87
Likes: 36
From: Ozarks
Year: 2001
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
[QUOTE=
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else./QUOTE]
I would have to agree with this. I have a 98 with a 3.5” lift and an 01 with 4”. Both have stock driveshafts with no transfer case drop and no vibrations.
Have you checked the play in transfer case output shaft?
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else./QUOTE]
I would have to agree with this. I have a 98 with a 3.5” lift and an 01 with 4”. Both have stock driveshafts with no transfer case drop and no vibrations.
Have you checked the play in transfer case output shaft?
Last edited by Offroadnutz; May 1, 2025 at 05:14 PM.
ɹǝqɯǝW ɹoᴉuǝS





Joined: Sep 2023
Posts: 622
Likes: 164
From: Colorado
Year: 1992
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0 H.O.
[QUOTE=Offroadnutz;3729757]
I would have to agree with this. I have a 98 with a 3.5” lift and an 01 with 4”. Both have stock driveshafts with no transfer case drop and no vibrations.
Have you checked the play in transfer case output shaft?
I disagree. I have a 92 with 3" lift and it would regularly eat u-joints every 5k to 6k miles.
Originally Posted by
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else./QUOTE
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else./QUOTE
I would have to agree with this. I have a 98 with a 3.5” lift and an 01 with 4”. Both have stock driveshafts with no transfer case drop and no vibrations.
Have you checked the play in transfer case output shaft?
Thread Starter
Member

Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 100
Likes: 4
From: Northeast
Year: 97
Model: Cherokee
Engine: 4.0L
Where do you feel the vibration? Hands, feet, butt in your seat.
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Where do you feel the vibration? Hands, feet, butt in your seat.
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Sye for a 2.5" lift is rather unnecessary and if that's the ultimate solution I'd argue your compensating for something else.
Are your leaf spring bolts tight, u bolts tight, does your rear axle have any pinion slop, are the locating tabs on the sides of your pinion yoke still there or has one/both broken off?
Because I doubt myself whether an SYE is worth it to be it, I just put only my front driveshaft on and went on the highway 75MPH. I did not want to do this but this problem has been driving me nuts and I had to make sure. The whole time, it drove like what a 90s Jeep with 31s should drive like - not like a new car, but fine. Someone wouldn't get in the passenger seat and think "Wow this drives like ****". I thought maybe I was doing the whole placebo thing to myself, so I got off the highway, put my rear driveshaft back on, and instantly noticed the difference as soon as I gave it the gas to merge back onto the highway. On the highway it felt worse, in my seat, in the floor pans. I also gauged how much the lid of my console was vibrating when I placed my hand on on the first drive, and it was 2x worse. The clearest sign was how my glove box and console contents had been silent on the initial drive, but they were now back to their normal chattering from vibrations.
So that confirms it for me. I don't know why shimming didn't work(I used a gauge to confirm angles were good), I don't know why the t case drop only made a small difference, and I don't know why even a new driveshaft only made it worse. But there is no questioning it's at least drivetrain related.
I checked, there is no play in my T case output shaft, and it seems to be straight(See Video). My diff went bad a few years ago and I got the same one w/ correct gearing from a junkyard, (150k on it). The pinion does have some amount of rotational play in it,or "slop", but that is backlash right? Should I measure it? I also did have to re-tighten the pinion bolt when I swapped it, and went a little over the max torque to get the correct amount of preload. I don't remember if these vibrations were as bad before I swapped it out. I also don't think it has any locating tabs either, I googled it and couldn't find any photos of what they would look like.
All my rear suspension is about two years old, I have a shackle lift and I think that may be why it's harder to get the driveshaft angled correctly. Without shims, it is literally the perfect angle for an SYE. All bolts are tightened.
CF Veteran
Joined: Aug 2018
Posts: 1,892
Likes: 345
From: Idaho
Year: 89
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: Peddles
I bet ujoints are toast probly about 50,000 mikes ago.
The pinion is a rotating preload. Its not something you can just squash the nut down to a certain ft lb.
Rereading i see you bought another driveshaft so ujoints might be okay. After seeing you messed with the pinion i might start there. However im unsure if you have the ability to even get any additional tourge in that nut to screw it up.
What axle, 35 or 8.25?
The pinion is a rotating preload. Its not something you can just squash the nut down to a certain ft lb.
Rereading i see you bought another driveshaft so ujoints might be okay. After seeing you messed with the pinion i might start there. However im unsure if you have the ability to even get any additional tourge in that nut to screw it up.
What axle, 35 or 8.25?
Last edited by EvanM; May 3, 2025 at 11:38 PM.
Trending Topics
ɹǝqɯǝW ɹoᴉuǝS





Joined: Sep 2023
Posts: 622
Likes: 164
From: Colorado
Year: 1992
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0 H.O.
Newbie
Joined: May 2025
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
From: Taxatwo****s
Year: 2001
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
I have Vibrations on the highway (2.5 inch lift), I've diagnosed its coming from the driveshaft.
I have the proper angles for a conventional driveshaft, but they are still present. T Case drop didn't help either. Ready to go with an SYE, I called Tom's driveshafts to figure out the logistics and they heavily persuaded against a Hack N Tap. They say the vibrations are worse then with a proper SYE. But maybe they're biased because they have customers call them who botched the installation and say the driveshaft is at fault.
Realistically, If I go for the Hack N Tap and do it right, is it going to be worse than with a Proper SYE? I really don't feel like opening up the transfer case and starting that whole can of worms. I could always switch the hack n tap out if vibrations are still present after I get the custom driveshaft, assuming I can make the hack n tap the same length as what an SYE would be.
It's not my tires, its not my front suspension, its not my front drive shaft, my exhaust is not hitting the crossmember.I bought another balanced conventional driveshaft with new u joints and it was somehow even worse on the highway. I need a double cardan
I have the proper angles for a conventional driveshaft, but they are still present. T Case drop didn't help either. Ready to go with an SYE, I called Tom's driveshafts to figure out the logistics and they heavily persuaded against a Hack N Tap. They say the vibrations are worse then with a proper SYE. But maybe they're biased because they have customers call them who botched the installation and say the driveshaft is at fault.
Realistically, If I go for the Hack N Tap and do it right, is it going to be worse than with a Proper SYE? I really don't feel like opening up the transfer case and starting that whole can of worms. I could always switch the hack n tap out if vibrations are still present after I get the custom driveshaft, assuming I can make the hack n tap the same length as what an SYE would be.
It's not my tires, its not my front suspension, its not my front drive shaft, my exhaust is not hitting the crossmember.I bought another balanced conventional driveshaft with new u joints and it was somehow even worse on the highway. I need a double cardan
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mrtoofast4u
Stock Grand Cherokee Tech. All ZJ/WJ/WK Non-modified/stock questions go here!
2
Jun 20, 2012 11:02 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)




