I dont believe there was ever a factory option for the visor. Anyhow yes the MJ and XJ visors are different. The roof lines are different so if you have an MJ you need to get an MJ specific visor and vis versa for the XJ.

I will seriously buy this if you still have it! I'll either pay for shipping or come pick it up!!

...Seriously

Here's one for an XJ for sale. https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f73/lu...-skids-143256/