Rebuilt engine starter behaving oddly
#16
No, still trying to figure out what is wrong. I have verified the rotor cap is right at the #1 plug wire at TDC. More to check, I guess. the noise was just so odd I thought that I might have a starter issue. That does not appear to be the case.
#17
Seasoned Member
Listening to that last video while watching the flexplate turn, it really seems like the sound is actually the load getting harder and easier on the starter. It sounds like you're already looking over the firing order and distributer indexing, which is where I would start.
#18
Listening to that last video while watching the flexplate turn, it really seems like the sound is actually the load getting harder and easier on the starter. It sounds like you're already looking over the firing order and distributer indexing, which is where I would start.
Thanks!
#20
Seasoned Member
I'm a RENIX era guy, can't help with the connector, but could it be to the sync sensor at the bottom of the distributor or to the AC pressure switch?
Remove the coil wire from the distributor cap and crank the engine. Does it still do that labored/free cranking thing?
Remove the coil wire from the distributor cap and crank the engine. Does it still do that labored/free cranking thing?
#22
CF Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 3,914
Received 1,084 Likes
on
868 Posts
Year: 1989
Model: Comanche (MJ)
Engine: 4.0
Listening to that last video while watching the flexplate turn, it really seems like the sound is actually the load getting harder and easier on the starter. It sounds like you're already looking over the firing order and distributer indexing, which is where I would start.
#24
It look that way to me as well, and the last video looks like it slows down versus stopping. Also seems like it's turning pretty slow. Have you verified spark and fuel? The Renix ignition won't fire if the voltage is sagging too low or the engine rpm is too slow. Are you cables up to snuff, including the block to battery ground wire? If you didn't remove the crank sensor from the bellhousing when you pulled the engine, you might have damaged it.
I don’t now how fast it should turn so I didn’t think it was going too slow. Something to check after I play around with the timing some more.
Thank you for the thoughts.
#25
Yes, I have done that a few times and it makes no difference.
#26
Seasoned Member
Lawsoncl is pointing out that if the CPS is not removed first, it can make contact with the tone ring on the flexplate when the engine is separated from the transmission. That contact can damage the CPS, but if you have spark, it is likely still functioning. I'm sure you've done it, but I would verify again that the distributor is not 180 degrees out of time. I also find it unusual that you have the same starter symptoms without ignition connected. Do you have the means to perform a compression check on all cylinders?
#27
Lawsoncl is pointing out that if the CPS is not removed first, it can make contact with the tone ring on the flexplate when the engine is separated from the transmission. That contact can damage the CPS, but if you have spark, it is likely still functioning. I'm sure you've done it, but I would verify again that the distributor is not 180 degrees out of time. I also find it unusual that you have the same starter symptoms without ignition connected. Do you have the means to perform a compression check on all cylinders?
Thank you,
#28
CF Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2017
Posts: 3,914
Received 1,084 Likes
on
868 Posts
Year: 1989
Model: Comanche (MJ)
Engine: 4.0
How hard is the engine to turn with a wrench on the crank? I'm assuming you would have noticed whether it was very stiff when bolting up the t/c. Staring at the video in slo-mo, it looks like the engine speeds up when it's sounding unloaded. The rep rate on the audio where it seems to unload is about once every 1.1 sec, so maybe one cylinder is off? That works out to about 220 rpm if you assume it's just one stroke being easy.
#29
How hard is the engine to turn with a wrench on the crank? I'm assuming you would have noticed whether it was very stiff when bolting up the t/c. Staring at the video in slo-mo, it looks like the engine speeds up when it's sounding unloaded. The rep rate on the audio where it seems to unload is about once every 1.1 sec, so maybe one cylinder is off? That works out to about 220 rpm if you assume it's just one stroke being easy.
I will see what the compression test says.
#30
How hard is the engine to turn with a wrench on the crank? I'm assuming you would have noticed whether it was very stiff when bolting up the t/c. Staring at the video in slo-mo, it looks like the engine speeds up when it's sounding unloaded. The rep rate on the audio where it seems to unload is about once every 1.1 sec, so maybe one cylinder is off? That works out to about 220 rpm if you assume it's just one stroke being easy.