Jeep Cherokee Forum

Jeep Cherokee Forum (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/)
-   Modified XJ Cherokee Tech (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f67/)
-   -   ARB or Truetrac for the Rear... (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f67/arb-truetrac-rear-199752/)

Jrozar 09-27-2014 08:11 PM

ARB or Truetrac for the Rear...
 
OK I am having one of those doubting myself days, in the coming month I am planning to do my front and rear axles...

For the front I already have an ARB to install (picked it up for $300 used), the compressor is already mounted, I'm considering sleeving the dana 30, upgrading the axle shafts, and the front should be good to go...

For the rear I'm really having a dilemma on choosing between an ARB and a Truetrac...

I like to way a Posi performs on wet, snow, or icy services....but since I already have an ARB front and the compressor run....will I regret going with a truetrac and not an ARB?

This XJ will be used for off-roading and exploring, it will see some snow and slick roads but also desert terrain and rocks...

What would be my pro's and con's with each?

holycaveman 09-27-2014 08:32 PM

I would go arb because you are set already. I run a welded rear and have no issues on slick roads.

mentalbreakdown00 09-27-2014 08:33 PM

I have an Aussie and can only speak for it, to me though if you have an arb for the front, might as well do one in the rear...

Metmknice 09-27-2014 08:35 PM

ARB, you already have a compressor. Do it.

Jrozar 09-27-2014 09:27 PM

The Direction this is going I may be spending an extra $500 for an ARB

I've been trying to talk myself in to the truetrac to save $ .....but there will be a day that I may wish I did spend the $..

There is something you Gotta love a 29" tired XJ ARB locked front and rear....

Metmknice 09-27-2014 09:32 PM


Originally Posted by Jrozar (Post 2942703)
The Direction this is going I may be spending an extra $500 for an ARB

I've been trying to talk myself in to the truetrac to save $ .....but there will be a day that I may wish I did spend the $..

There is something you Gotta love a 29" tired XJ ARB locked front and rear....

This is one of those things that "you get what you pay for". Consider maybe a Yukon Zip locker? same as ARB, but a bit cheaper. I think better warranty too.

XJlimitedx99 09-27-2014 09:44 PM

I vote the arb also. You already have the compressor and you're already going to be paying to set the gears up.

Just think of how cool you'll sound telling people you got ARB's front and rear 8)

xjmarc 09-27-2014 10:19 PM

If you actually wheel it you'll hate a LSD. Lift a tire and it's about as useless as an open diff. Get a locker and leave the LSDs to the street rods.

Jrozar 09-28-2014 09:36 AM

So do they make a zip locker for the 8.25? What's your experience with it verse or Arb?


Originally Posted by Metmknice (Post 2942706)
This is one of those things that "you get what you pay for". Consider maybe a Yukon Zip locker? same as ARB, but a bit cheaper. I think better warranty too.


Muddz 09-28-2014 12:59 PM


Originally Posted by Jrozar (Post 2942911)
So do they make a zip locker for the 8.25? What's your experience with it verse or Arb?

I don't think there is a Zip Locker for the 8.25.

For off-road I would go with a locker or selectable locker.

Ianf406 09-28-2014 02:52 PM

Spend the cash (save if you have too) and get the ARB. Mine has been extremely reliable and works exactly like it is supposed to. You already have the compressor and everything plus you get another cool switch haha. That is my opinion.

Jrozar 09-28-2014 03:48 PM

Did you upgrade to the braided stainless lines or stay with the plastic?


Originally Posted by Ianf406 (Post 2943099)
Spend the cash (save if you have too) and get the ARB. Mine has been extremely reliable and works exactly like it is supposed to. You already have the compressor and everything plus you get another cool switch haha. That is my opinion.


CanXJ 09-28-2014 04:01 PM

Go with the ARB, mine has been issue free. I have the plastic lines, been OK so far. If you have old air hose you can run the line in that for protection. I carry a repair coupling and spare line in case I do break a line.

Ianf406 09-28-2014 07:04 PM


Originally Posted by Jrozar (Post 2943143)
Did you upgrade to the braided stainless lines or stay with the plastic?

I stayed with the plastic wrapped in convoluted tubing/routed high. This one has been in for about 5.5 years and its held up through all kinds of abuse. My last one (different Jeep) Lasted about 10 years and was still going when I sold it.

I did not know about the braided line... Might be worth it. Good routing will save it from most everything though.

macgyver35 09-28-2014 10:08 PM

While many, actually nearly everyone, is suggesting going with the ARB, consider this...

If you daily drive this, an LSD in the rear can be really beneficial for those unforeseen slick spots or black ice mixed in with dry pavement during you daily commute. There may be light rain that you don't want to do a full lock-up for, but the LSD would handle it well.

When you go off-road, you'll have the LSD and the ARB.

Just my opinion, but you know how that goes...

caronaxtr 09-29-2014 10:58 AM

I'd go ARB in the rear, as stated in many other posts you've got the compressor. I've got a Yukon Zip in my D30 & an ARB in the 8.25. Great setup. On when you want them to be & off (open diff) when you don't.

Check out RWK Haus on here. I bought all my gears / lockers through Robert. Prices were great & service was great also. He's a vendor on here..

mr.badwrench 09-29-2014 12:48 PM

If you do a lot of street driving go with an arb, if its mostly off road you cant beat a Detroit for durability and a soild lock up every time, they can be a bit of a pain on the street if you see wet or icy conditions and lock up when when you don't want it to. just my .02

Rock Toy 09-29-2014 03:22 PM

I guess I'm going with everyone else on here, the Detroit TruTrac isn't a locker, but it works well enough as long as the tires stay on the ground which isn't always the case when on serious trails. The ARB is a locker, and if installed properly with the air lines routed to protect them, it gives you the best of both worlds. Locked when needed and open when a locker isn't wanted.

Jrozar 09-30-2014 07:53 PM

Well....I pulled the trigger on a rear ARB and a 12ft stainless air
Line...so it will have front and rear selectable lockers.

gettin_dirty_with_ruby 09-30-2014 09:48 PM

What did the stainless line cost?

toddreg 10-01-2014 11:35 AM

Thoughts on another idea?
 
I am in the same dilemma. I have an ARB up front already with the compressor of course. I also have the Country version so I have a TruTrak in the rear and it does not get the job done plain and simple.

I am thinking about an Eaton electric locker for the rear primarily due to having an alternative system should the compressor or lines loose pressure to the front locker. This way I should always have one of the two systems functioning.

Your thoughts and comments please.

Stlavguy 10-01-2014 08:21 PM

Don't forget about OX, they are fantastic

CanXJ 10-02-2014 01:20 PM


Originally Posted by toddreg (Post 2945045)
I am in the same dilemma. I have an ARB up front already with the compressor of course. I also have the Country version so I have a TruTrak in the rear and it does not get the job done plain and simple.

I am thinking about an Eaton electric locker for the rear primarily due to having an alternative system should the compressor or lines loose pressure to the front locker. This way I should always have one of the two systems functioning.

Your thoughts and comments please.

If you have a C8.25 rearend you will have a hard time finding a E-Locker, nobody makes one. If you are wanting a selectable locker you are limited to a Air Locker.

Stlavguy 10-03-2014 07:31 AM


Originally Posted by CanXJ (Post 2945678)
If you have a C8.25 rearend you will have a hard time finding a E-Locker, nobody makes one. If you are wanting a selectable locker you are limited to a Air Locker.

You are wrong, look at OX its selectable it can be opperated by air or electric or mechanical lever or even a simple " drive away lock" if you don't want any of that. On top of it all as the last guy asked, he's afraid if one system fails he wants another. Here Ya go! Plus if even that fails you have a backup with the drive away lock. ARB can't do that...
I have an OX in my 8.25 with the electric actuator, it's awesome. Switch off, open axle. Flip the switch instant solid locker.

CanXJ 10-03-2014 01:23 PM


Originally Posted by Stlavguy (Post 2946141)
You are wrong, look at OX its selectable it can be opperated by air or electric or mechanical lever or even a simple " drive away lock" if you don't want any of that. On top of it all as the last guy asked, he's afraid if one system fails he wants another. Here Ya go! Plus if even that fails you have a backup with the drive away lock. ARB can't do that...
I have an OX in my 8.25 with the electric actuator, it's awesome. Switch off, open axle. Flip the switch instant solid locker.

First time for everything :laughing:

seniorgreenpants 10-03-2014 01:45 PM

I too vote for the ARB, I only have experience with Spartan Lockers. SHOOT besides ground clearance lockers are a great investment. My last outing i was keeping up with xjs with 33's and 4.5" open open. My little front and rear spartans got me through, just had to pick a different line with my ground clearance limit.

Side note not a fan of the harshness of my rear spartan on the street. Thats why I have an ARB for the rear when I lift. Already mounted in a housing with 4.56 gears.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:05 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands