front diff squeal, pinion?
#1
CF Veteran
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: CO
Posts: 1,011
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
18 Posts
Year: 99
Model: Cherokee (XJ)
Engine: 4.0
front diff squeal, pinion?
99, 4.56, np242/auto, hp30-open, 33s, 213,756
hey all,
the situation boils down as such,
Ive been trying to find a front end squeal for a month now. For a long while I thought it was brake related because its the only thing that wasnt as new as the rest of the moving parts.
Brakes: installed myselft, napa composite rotor, Hawk HSE pads, 3 years old all in good condition. I greased the slides and thought this solved the issue for a day, nope.
Gears: USA standard 4.56 and USA master install kit from RWK,- 22,300 miles on them, professional 4x4 shop installed .007 backlash, bearing preload 15ftlbs. ring gear 55lbs, bearing caps 60flbs, under 1.1 year old, Pinion seems like where the whine/squeal is coming from- 10 mph or under, .5-1mm side/side up/down play, 1mm in/out maybe, its still very solid feeling.The diff fluid was changed at the advised 500 mile mark and checked every 10,000 after. The noise is very high pitched, similar to brakes, and while braking it will change rpm almost to a skip/chirp, but I do not believe the brakes are this issue still- idk know how to 100% rule these out other than somehow removing and capping lines.
Hubs: installed myself, all torqued properly, 3 month old timken, very confident these are not making this noise
-just removed front DS because of vibes, slip joint wiggled at 70 mph, need new shaft likely
- ill be contacting the 4x4 shop tomorrow just to pick their brain.
ive only been able to replicate this noise once by jacking up a tire and spinning it today. Normally this sound is only at low speed, fairly consistent, but not 100% of the time, sometimes is takes turning a bit to put load onto something to squeak no matter right or left, nor does it squeal always while turning. It will not make this sound driving in reverse and it does still make the noise with the DS removed.
If a pinion bearing is the culprit, which one is likely bad (inner/outer) and how will a shop check? How can I check?
I worry about bringing it in and being told its bad even, if it isnt just so they could charge- ide like to think not, but its why other than this I never let shops "fix" my vehicle anymore.
I also worry that if I was to check everything myself, they would know its new diff oil and not stand behind their work blaming me for tampering, easily done. Dont get me wrong, these guys were very thorough on a complete inspection of the vehicle which is standard for them, they nailed many other unrelated issues upon inspection.
If it is the pinion, I believe the DS played a rolln in damaging it, not the shop, but I dont know enough to be sure. Youtube hasnt provided any replication of this noise for bearing related noises.
I feel like im up S__T creek on this one.
Lastly, if a pinion bearing is bad, how will this progress as its driven, its my only wheels DD?
Thank you immensely for your input!
~Matt
hey all,
the situation boils down as such,
Ive been trying to find a front end squeal for a month now. For a long while I thought it was brake related because its the only thing that wasnt as new as the rest of the moving parts.
Brakes: installed myselft, napa composite rotor, Hawk HSE pads, 3 years old all in good condition. I greased the slides and thought this solved the issue for a day, nope.
Gears: USA standard 4.56 and USA master install kit from RWK,- 22,300 miles on them, professional 4x4 shop installed .007 backlash, bearing preload 15ftlbs. ring gear 55lbs, bearing caps 60flbs, under 1.1 year old, Pinion seems like where the whine/squeal is coming from- 10 mph or under, .5-1mm side/side up/down play, 1mm in/out maybe, its still very solid feeling.The diff fluid was changed at the advised 500 mile mark and checked every 10,000 after. The noise is very high pitched, similar to brakes, and while braking it will change rpm almost to a skip/chirp, but I do not believe the brakes are this issue still- idk know how to 100% rule these out other than somehow removing and capping lines.
Hubs: installed myself, all torqued properly, 3 month old timken, very confident these are not making this noise
-just removed front DS because of vibes, slip joint wiggled at 70 mph, need new shaft likely
- ill be contacting the 4x4 shop tomorrow just to pick their brain.
ive only been able to replicate this noise once by jacking up a tire and spinning it today. Normally this sound is only at low speed, fairly consistent, but not 100% of the time, sometimes is takes turning a bit to put load onto something to squeak no matter right or left, nor does it squeal always while turning. It will not make this sound driving in reverse and it does still make the noise with the DS removed.
If a pinion bearing is the culprit, which one is likely bad (inner/outer) and how will a shop check? How can I check?
I worry about bringing it in and being told its bad even, if it isnt just so they could charge- ide like to think not, but its why other than this I never let shops "fix" my vehicle anymore.
I also worry that if I was to check everything myself, they would know its new diff oil and not stand behind their work blaming me for tampering, easily done. Dont get me wrong, these guys were very thorough on a complete inspection of the vehicle which is standard for them, they nailed many other unrelated issues upon inspection.
If it is the pinion, I believe the DS played a rolln in damaging it, not the shop, but I dont know enough to be sure. Youtube hasnt provided any replication of this noise for bearing related noises.
I feel like im up S__T creek on this one.
Lastly, if a pinion bearing is bad, how will this progress as its driven, its my only wheels DD?
Thank you immensely for your input!
~Matt
Last edited by 4x4jeepmanthing; 08-21-2018 at 04:37 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
BillyBoy
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
28
08-04-2016 10:00 AM
not_entirely_clueless
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
2
07-11-2012 10:34 AM
Troth
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
9
03-24-2010 11:43 AM
evmo
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
2
09-23-2009 09:05 AM
sk8ertht540s
Stock XJ Cherokee Tech. All XJ Non-modified/stock questions go here
13
09-10-2009 10:09 AM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)