Jeep Cherokee Forum

Jeep Cherokee Forum (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/)
-   Modified XJ Cherokee Tech (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f67/)
-   -   Exhaust Manifold: Stock vs Headers for MPG (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f67/exhaust-manifold-stock-vs-headers-mpg-213436/)

s346k 09-01-2015 02:15 PM

i understand the venture effect. however, I do not understand how air and any liquid can be compared physically, I digress. nonetheless, set up a venturi tube and force your choice of content through it. poke a hole in it. it's going to leak...


I've had numerous cars with exhaust leaks before the o2. those same cars had wideband o2 sensors on them. none of the exhaust leaks altered the afr. a gaping hole pre-o2, yeah that'll cause a problem. something the size of that crack in your header...? no.

toasterknight 09-01-2015 02:24 PM

Exhaust Manifold: Stock vs Headers for MPG
 

Originally Posted by s346k (Post 3136024)
i understand the venture effect. however, I do not understand how air and any liquid can be compared physically, I digress. nonetheless, set up a venturi tube and force your choice of content through it. poke a hole in it. it's going to leak...


I've had numerous cars with exhaust leaks before the o2. those same cars had wideband o2 sensors on them. none of the exhaust leaks altered the afr. a gaping hole pre-o2, yeah that'll cause a problem. something the size of that crack in your header...? no.

When it refers to the way things flow gases and liquids behave identically which is why they are called fluids.

Did you see the video?

s346k 09-01-2015 02:49 PM

yeah, I saw the video. I understand the scavenging qualities of a header collector, vacuum effect, etc. I'm arguing that a crack in the manifold is going to cause a rich condition as described.


edit: one thing that video is failing to acknowledge is backpressure and exhaust pulses. not only could I see carbon around the crack in the manifold, I could also feel the exhaust exiting with my finger. not to mention, my primaries on my stock header showed signs of being hot and 4 of the 6 plugs have looked a bit lean with or without the crack in the manifold.

mschi772 09-01-2015 04:32 PM

Exhaust Manifold: Stock vs Headers for MPG
 
Gas is a fluid. You can't argue or disagree with this. Whether you understand it or not does not change physics.

Negative pressure at a crack does not always happen. Just because the stars aren't always aligned for it to happen doesn't change the fact that it can and does happen.

toasterknight 09-01-2015 05:07 PM

Exhaust Manifold: Stock vs Headers for MPG
 

Originally Posted by mschi772 (Post 3136080)
Gas is a fluid. You can't argue or disagree with this. Whether you understand it or not does not change physics.

Negative pressure at a crack does not always happen. Just because the stars aren't always aligned for it to happen doesn't change the fact that it can and does happen.

Thank you.

s346k 09-02-2015 01:36 AM

my jeep defies physics. it should be in a museum.

toasterknight 09-02-2015 01:57 AM

Exhaust Manifold: Stock vs Headers for MPG
 

Originally Posted by s346k (Post 3136263)
my jeep defies physics. it should be in a museum.

It doesn't defy physics. The cracks just not in the right spot.

black_771 09-02-2015 07:50 AM


Originally Posted by s346k (Post 3135791)
my stock manifold was cracked. I don't buy the lean condition caused by a cracked manifold. how does air get sucked into a highly pressurized system through an opening thinner than a sheet of paper? I saw no different mpg after repairing the manifold. I can only assume a more efficient header will afford a mileage increase assuming you aren't frequently employing the newfound efficiency with the skinny pedal.


Honestly, there are many possible factors controlling why yours may not be having an issue including where the crack is in relation to the sensors, however the issue of a cracked manifold sucking in air and throwing off the sensor really isn't debatable. Its a common occurrence and easily repeatable.

J3ff3ry_J33pst3r 12-03-2015 04:00 PM


Originally Posted by s346k (Post 3135791)
my stock manifold was cracked. I don't buy the lean condition caused by a cracked manifold. how does air get sucked into a highly pressurized system through an opening thinner than a sheet of paper? I saw no different mpg after repairing the manifold. I can only assume a more efficient header will afford a mileage increase assuming you aren't frequently employing the newfound efficiency with the skinny pedal.

Wow.
You do realize that metal expands when heated , right? Heh, this is a topic that's been covered & validated for ,like,ever ? A cracked manifold does suck air in as it expands ....it can expell the same type of air that appears to flow plentifully between your ears ,as well....
:icon_confused:


Srry to butt-in ,but as I read this reply I just..... sheez.....

ArcticXJ 12-04-2015 03:04 PM

0

s346k 12-04-2015 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by J3ff3ry_J33pst3r (Post 3179721)
Wow.
You do realize that metal expands when heated , right? Heh, this is a topic that's been covered & validated for ,like,ever ? A cracked manifold does suck air in as it expands ....it can expell the same type of air that appears to flow plentifully between your ears ,as well....
:icon_confused:


Srry to butt-in ,but as I read this reply I just..... sheez.....

are you implying an exhaust leak will get larger as the parts warm up?

Fred/N0AZZ 12-05-2015 09:58 AM

:popcorn: :popcorn:

Jamie57 12-05-2015 01:09 PM


Originally Posted by Fred/N0AZZ (Post 3180484)
:popcorn: :popcorn:


Move over Fred. I gotta watch this too.

gpXJ 12-08-2015 12:57 PM


Originally Posted by Jamie57 (Post 3180534)
Move over Fred. I gotta watch this too.

You boys move to the corners so I can plop down in the middle, there's plenty of room on this couch :brickwall:

poorboy76 12-08-2015 01:18 PM

Screw studying for finals...I'm going to sit back and learn all I need right here.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:53 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands