Jeep Cherokee Forum

Jeep Cherokee Forum (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/)
-   Cherokee Chat (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f59/)
-   -   To carry a spare or not to carry a spare, that is the question (https://www.cherokeeforum.com/f59/carry-spare-not-carry-spare-question-247201/)

samiam 09-27-2018 03:14 PM

To carry a spare or not to carry a spare, that is the question
 
Pros and cons of spare carry. Been off roading all my life with mostly ATVs and SXSs without a spare. I carry plugs and compressor and have gotten away with it. Had flats that I’ve plugged with some having to have a bunch of plugs to hold air and I’ve had a bead come loose that I had to improvise a little to get it to seal back up. I know if I went a long ways from home I could carry on the roof if needed and leave it at the trailhead. Just wanta hear other opinions.

firebane 09-27-2018 03:25 PM


Originally Posted by samiam (Post 3517403)
Pros and cons of spare carry. Been off roading all my life with mostly ATVs and SXSs without a spare. I carry plugs and compressor and have gotten away with it. Had flats that I’ve plugged with some having to have a bunch of plugs to hold air and I’ve had a bead come loose that I had to improvise a little to get it to seal back up. I know if I went a long ways from home I could carry on the roof if needed and leave it at the trailhead. Just wanta hear other opinions.

I'd say once you get over a 33 tire even possibly a 32 a spare is just a lot of extra weight and uneeded.

WyoCherokee 09-27-2018 03:26 PM

better safe than sorry.

unidentifiedbomb 09-27-2018 04:40 PM

A 33 can be fitted in the back without the hatch panel and the bench up. So i don't see the reason why not to carry a spare up to a 33". I have to drop the rear bench to secure my 35" spare now but I think it helps with the center of gravity and it's always better safe than sorry.

samiam 09-27-2018 05:03 PM


Originally Posted by unidentifiedbomb (Post 3517415)
A 33 can be fitted in the back without the hatch panel and the bench up. So i don't see the reason why not to carry a spare up to a 33". I have to drop the rear bench to secure my 35" spare now but I think it helps with the center of gravity and it's always better safe than sorry.


I’ve seen a 31” in the back but not a 33. Can you elaborate with some pics too??? I guess the reasons why I don’t want to carry is that I have 33s and don’t want the extra weight hanging off the back as well as the high $ of a rear tire carrier bumper.

unidentifiedbomb 09-27-2018 06:20 PM

Lay the 33" spare down, shut the hatch with the bench up. 31" spare is the biggest you can fit in the stock spare location.

Rogue4x4 09-27-2018 07:32 PM

Punch a hole in the sidewall and you'll wish you had one, lol...


Martlor13 09-27-2018 08:22 PM


Originally Posted by firebane (Post 3517405)
I'd say once you get over a 33 tire even possibly a 32 a spare is just a lot of extra weight and uneeded.

unneeded? If you do any wheeling out in the middle of nowhere a spare is most definitely needed

Turbo X_J 09-27-2018 08:33 PM

"To carry a spare or not to carry a spare, that is the question"

If 12+1 won't do it, it's time to do something else...

RockinRonnie 09-27-2018 10:08 PM

To me would depend on were you would be wheeling the farther or more remote the more you should carry a spare! really comes down to how far do you want to walk?

tinytrax78 09-28-2018 07:14 AM

I carry my 34x10.50 swamper on my roof rack ,its like a gun, id rather have it and not need it THEN need it and not have it !!!

Rogue4x4 09-28-2018 08:29 AM


Originally Posted by tinytrax78 (Post 3517518)
I carry my 34x10.50 swamper on my roof rack ,its like a gun, id rather have it and not need it THEN need it and not have it !!!

This is my wheeling mantra.

For daily driving, I don't carry a spare, that's why I have AAA. As for offroad, I don't carry an entire wheel, just a tire. That and a couple of tire spoons. Lay the tire down flat, and use the space inside it as storage....maximizes cargo. I mount and balance my own tires anyway, so it's a good practice to be familiar with.

bad_idea 09-28-2018 11:33 PM

I'm with roninofako. No spare needed around town, always carry one when I go off road. Why fight with plugging tires and resetting beads, assuming you don't slice a sidewall, when you can just change a tire? I have 33s. I set my spare flat in the cargo area. Put a board on top of the tire and you have the same storage space, just elevated a foot higher.

DustyWagoneer 09-28-2018 11:58 PM


Originally Posted by bad_idea (Post 3517666)
I'm with roninofako. No spare needed around town, always carry one when I go off road. Why fight with plugging tires and resetting beads, assuming you don't slice a sidewall, when you can just change a tire? I have 33s. I set my spare flat in the cargo area. Put a board on top of the tire and you have the same storage space, just elevated a foot higher.

That's a good idea, bad_idea! :D

When I went to Ouray, CO I ratchet-straped it to the top of my roof. I ended up making four of the holes in the black rail a little larger to accept the hooks on the ratchet straps.
HAHA The spare ended up staying up there for about a month after I got back to Kommiefornia.

bad_idea 09-29-2018 12:02 AM

My 33x12.5 on a steel wheel weighs in at 75 lbs or so. I'm not hoisting that over my head. Irritating enough to lift into the back of the jeep.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:56 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands