Yesterday I was hearing a rattle on the front of the engine, and couldn't figure out where it was coming from.
Today I persisted and did some prying on the pulleys etc, and finally found that the water pump pulley would move quite a bit when pryed on.

So after reading on here about not getting into a rebuilt pump, I just bought a new one from Oreilly auto parts. They are my go-to store now for Jeep parts.....
Just over 40 bucks for a NEW pump.....

I'm gonna paint it before I change it.....